fbpx
Market intelligence for international student recruitment from ICEF
7th Jun 2023

Are US colleges ready for the projected enrolment cliff?

Short on time? Here are the highlights:
  • The population of high-school graduates in the US is expected to peak in 2025 and then decline sharply afterwards
  • This, along with other economic and labour market factors, is expected to trigger an “enrolment cliff” for US higher education
  • More international enrolments are likely to be an important counterpoint for any decline in domestic student numbers and tuition fees
  • Not all US colleges, however, are ready or able to invest in expanded recruitment overseas

There is a widening conversation in the United States – among demographers, academics, and enrolment management specialists – of an approaching "enrolment cliff" for US higher education.

The idea is underpinned in part by long-term projections for the population of high-school graduates in the US. The analysis around such trends can be complex, but the short story is that the number of students finishing high school in America is expected to peak around 2025 and to decline sharply from there.

Writing in Vox, Kevin Carey traces the issue back to the 2008/09 global economic crisis, which, he explains, "Created a bomb with an 18-year fuse: birth rates immediately reversed course and began to plummet." Looking ahead, he adds that, "In four years, the number of students graduating from high schools across the country will begin a sudden and precipitous decline, due to a rolling demographic aftershock of the Great Recession. Traumatized by uncertainty and unemployment, people decided to stop having kids during that period. But even as we climbed out of the recession, the birth rate kept dropping, and we are now starting to see the consequences on campuses everywhere. Classes will shrink, year after year, for most of the next two decades."

If that pattern plays out as projected, it will surely exacerbate the decade-long decline in total higher education enrolment in the US. The National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) reports that between fall 2010 and fall 2021, total undergraduate enrolment in degree-granting institutions decreased by 15% (from 18.1 million to 15.4 million students). Total post-graduate enrolment increased marginally over the same period.

Not all institutions will be affected equally. While the more elite, selective institutions are not expected to see any significant declines, the wider field of US colleges are at greater risk.

The bottom line, however, is that the coming demographic, economic, and labour market shifts are significant enough that colleges of all shapes and sizes will have to factor them in their planning.

“Regardless of whether they’re drawing prospective students from nearby states or their own backyard, institutions need to build a strategy to compensate for a smaller pool of prospects,” says Kelly Iler, an account executive at Mongoose Research.

The research specialists at Mongoose, and other observers in and around the higher education system, anticipate a more active and sophisticated recruitment effort on the part of US colleges, including a greater focus on student retention, streamlining admissions processes, and on expanded programme delivery for remote and hybrid learners.

We can also expect that international students will continue to figure more prominently in the enrolment strategies of US colleges. “International students play a critical role in securing long-term tuition revenue for higher education institutions and in filling much-needed talent gaps in an already stressed labour market,” said Lucy Stonehill, CEO of edtech company BridgeU. “This is a growing, diverse pool of prospective applicants with strong academic foundations and robust English language skills."

A recent report from BridgeU makes the point in analysing post-secondary applications data from 32,000 international school graduates across 142 countries. The study finds resurgent interest in US higher education on the part of Chinese students, but also from key emerging markets in Africa, South Asia, and Southeast Asia.

There are signs as well that US institutions are leaving behind the historical emphasis that many have had on so-called "armchair recruiting" in favour of a more active recruitment posture. A recent survey of US colleges found that more than six in ten were actively engaged with education agents, for example. “This is a sector-wide shift,” says Patrik Pavlacic of research specialist BONARD (the company behind the survey). “And it will be interesting to monitor the situation in the immediate future, as the sector moves on from the pandemic crisis and study destinations globally compete aggressively for student recruitment.”

That shift certainly appears to be widespread, but it doesn't necessarily mean that all US colleges have already taken steps to ensure internal alignment around expanded international recruitment, or that more institutions are prepared to invest further in building international markets. Speaking to Inside Higher Ed during the recent NAFSA conference in Washington, D.C., Nikita Kotelnikov, sales manager for Keystone Education Group, expressed frustration that recruiting budgets remained soft at some colleges even as they aimed to counter the forecasted erosion of domestic enrolment with greater international student numbers.

“They are not adapting fast enough to the way this field is changing,” he said, comparing US institutions to Canadian ones, which were thriving post-pandemic. “At this point, my fear is that without investing more [in international student recruitment], many of the smaller schools may not survive.”

For additional background, please see:

Most Recent

  • The rise of alternative destinations: Thailand, Poland, and the Philippines Read More
  • Comparing student visa proof of funds requirements across 20 study destinations Read More
  • ICEF Podcast: Start-ups in international education: disrupters or innovators? Read More

Most Popular

  • Canada’s foreign enrolment grew by more than 30% in 2022 Read More
  • Measuring cost of study and cost of living across study destinations Read More
  • Recruiting in the Emirates: Big goals, world-class education, and new scholarships Read More

Because you found this article interesting

The rise of alternative destinations: Thailand, Poland, and the Philippines A growing body of industry research shows that in 2024, international students are considering a wider range of...
Read more
France hosted 412,000 foreign students in 2022/23 Campus France has released its international student enrolment data for 2022/23, and in contrast to the double-digit percentage...
Read more
Hong Kong needs to build more student housing In his October 2023 address, Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee set out some ambitious goals for the...
Read more
Canadian immigration minister releases official cap figures and targets for 2024 In many respects, the implementation of Canada’s newly established cap on international student enrolment has been shrouded in...
Read more
Australia: Record-high foreign enrolment but tighter immigration settings now taking hold The Australian government has further increased its scrutiny of international student applicants in an effort to ensure incoming...
Read more
Business school survey again signals declining non-EU enrolment in UK The most recent survey from the Chartered Association of Business Schools in the UK reveals that, “International student...
Read more
US study visa refusals reached record levels in 2023 More than a third of prospective international students applying to study in the US last year were turned...
Read more
Canada: More provincial cap numbers announced; IRCC moves up end date for post-graduate work for partnership programmes Since the Canadian government’s announcement in January that it would be capping the number of new study permits...
Read more
What are you looking for?
Quick Links