fbpx
Market intelligence for international student recruitment from ICEF
31st Jul 2024

Under pressure: How global migration and economic trends are impacting international education

Short on time? Here are the highlights:
  • Immigration policies in several leading study abroad destinations are more restrictive in 2024 than in the past
  • They include efforts to curb the flow of new foreign students in a bid to reduce net migration
  • The new policies reflect declining public and political support for immigration and growing concern about access to affordable housing and rising costs of living

It all seemed to happen quite suddenly, and then relentlessly. Beginning in mid 2023 and stretching through 2024, several national governments – notably those in the UK, Australia, and Canada – tightened immigration settings, increased scrutiny of education providers and agents, and made it more difficult for foreign students to obtain visas. In the Netherlands, universities committed to reducing international student volumes to avoid imminent legislative intervention.

We came to expect an announcement every week or two – whether it was news of an immediate cap on new study permits, a massive visa application fee increase, higher financial requirements for students, amendments to work rights, or the withdrawal of most dependants’ permission to accompany students.

The question is: why? Why would governments act to stem the flow of bright international students capable of alleviating critical skills shortages and declining economic productivity? What ended a post-pandemic enthusiasm for welcoming record-high numbers of foreign students?

The answer lies in declining public support for immigration amidst persistent economic pressures and a global migration crisis that is overwhelming critical infrastructure such as healthcare systems and housing.

A quick shift in priorities

The more restrictive policies signal that the cultural and economic value of international students is now secondary to an urgent new priority for elected governments in many advanced economies: reducing migration at seemingly any cost.

Among policy makers, there appears to be little memory of – or concern about – the devastating toll of plummeting international student numbers during the COVID-19 pandemic. Interrupted student mobility flows when borders were closed impacted not only the revenues and staff of education providers, but also the fortunes of whole communities and other business sectors.

When borders reopened, governments enacted all manner of policies to attract new international students, knowing full well that billions of dollars would return to their economies as a result. Foreign enrolments quickly surged to record-high levels in Australia (nearly 800,000 in 2023), Canada (over 1 million in 2023), and the UK (nearly 700,000 in higher education alone in 2021/22).

But in tandem with these new peaks, more and more stories appeared in national media outlets about a disturbing trend: growing numbers of people in major cities in Australia, Canada, the UK, and elsewhere are struggling to access affordable housing and other vital services, including healthcare. And all this amidst a backdrop of surging inflation, rising costs of living, and economic uncertainty.

These factors combined for a potent political cocktail that has made immigration a hot-button electoral issue in leading study abroad destinations. For example, in Canada, 50% of Canadians responding to a survey conducted by Leger in February 2024 said that “there are too many new immigrants in Canada” — a proportion that more than doubled over January 2023. This stands in sharp contrast to a long-standing belief in previous decades among most Canadians that immigration is a public good.

A global crisis of movement

The world is facing what some have termed a global migration crisis, characterised by historically high numbers of people attempting to cross borders in search of safety and opportunity. The crisis stems from a horrible combination of wars, natural disasters, and crumbling economies. Any or all of these elements are present in dozens of countries, especially in the Global South (a designation generally understood to contain large swaths of Africa, Latin America, and Asia). Millions of people in affected regions face difficult or unsafe circumstances, and so many are driven to seek temporary or permanent settlement elsewhere.

UNESCO figures indicate that there were 281 million international migrants as of 2020 (the latest year for which global data has been compiled). Of that total, 169 million were labour migrants and 117 million were displaced people (mostly asylum and refugee claimants).

International students, who fall under the category of “temporary migrants,” currently number about 8 million worldwide. This segment is a drop in the bucket, even a rounding error, when you consider the total migrant population of over 280 million people. But international students are nevertheless caught up in the same migration politics. They are explicitly counted in net migration figures in the UK, for example, and in temporary migration figures in Canada.

What is to be done?

There is little debate about the following facts:

  1. Rising numbers of people moving from country to country do place pressure on local services, labour markets, and housing markets.
  2. There remains an undersupply of housing and healthcare services – and persistent concerns about rising costs of living – in many top destinations for international students.
  3. Growing segments of the public in those countries want to see immigration levels reduced. This has fuelled not only the rise of ultra-nationalist and/or far-right movements, but also more restrictive immigration policies in liberal democracies such as Australia, Canada, and the UK.
  4. What is sometimes known as the “social licence” afforded to the international education sector has been eroded due to shifts in public support for immigration, media coverage of unethical practices on the part of a small segment of education providers and agents, and a perception in some circles that the sector is more concerned with revenues than with the well-being of international students.

Across our industry, we all have a role to play in restoring the standing of international education in the eyes of government and the public. The way forward includes a renewed commitment to providing an outstanding study experience to all students: in the classroom, through student services, by securing more and better accommodation, and by improving graduate outcomes.

It will be crucial to:

  • Build stronger links between recruitment and housing availability;
  • Align recruitment with labour market needs;
  • Work in collaboration with industry and other stakeholders to ensure improved career outcomes for international students, both in their study destinations and at home;
  • Improve communications with government stakeholders and the public at large;
  • Advocate for international student numbers to be tracked separately from net migration figures.

This has been a year in which global political and economic pressures have had a profound impact on international student mobility. Among the many important lessons to be drawn from 2024 is how vulnerable our sector can be to changes in policy and how critical it is to communicate the benefits and standards of international education to policy makers and other key stakeholders.

For additional background, please see:

  • Join the ICEF Monitor Global Summit (23 September 23 2024, London). A landmark one-day summit bringing together the industry's senior leaders, policy makers, and experts, all focused on shaping the future of the international education sector.

Most Recent

  • Study shows that international students want a sense of belonging long before arriving on campus Read More
  • Mapping the student journey: Good data, student-centric strategies, and a customised CRM are must-haves Read More
  • How technology is helping to build better student payment systems Read More

Most Popular

  • Which countries will contribute the most to global student mobility in 2030? Read More
  • Research shows link between study abroad and poverty alleviation  Read More
  • Beyond the Big Four: How demand for study abroad is shifting to destinations in Asia and Europe Read More

Because you found this article interesting

New Zealand: International student enrolments up 67% in 2023 amid growing public support New Zealand’s international student enrolments are bouncing back amid strong public support for internationalisation. The recovery is taking...
Read more
Three international education trends for 2025: Revenue optimisation, marketing personalisation, and on-the-ground local intelligence TREND #1 DEMAND AND REVENUE OPTIMISATION “Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is...
Read more
Australia’s enrolment cap legislation is stalled. What happens next? Australia’s next federal election is expected to be held on or before 17 May 2025. It seems clear...
Read more
Canada confirms expansion of in-study work rights and new compliance requirements for institutions In July 2024, Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) proposed a series of regulatory changes to the country’s...
Read more
New research highlights the impact of policy on international enrolments A research collaboration by NAFSA, Oxford Test of English, and Studyportals indicates that institutions around the world are...
Read more
Canada ends expedited study permit processing for international students Canada began to offer fast-tracked study permit processing to international students from select countries in 2018 with the...
Read more
The way forward: Shifting to a more strategic and student-centred recruitment The following article is adapted from the 2025 edition of ICEF Insights magazine, which is freely available to...
Read more
Canada: Sector survey says collaboration between governments and institutions essential to avoid “long-term damage to the sector” A new IDP survey highlights the scale of the impact the Canadian government’s new immigration policies are having...
Read more
What are you looking for?
Quick Links