Market intelligence for international student recruitment from ICEF
13th Apr 2012

Is tuition discounting an effective recruitment strategy?

“Colleges and universities operate at the confluence of multiple pressures. The press to accomplish four objectives simultaneously - increase revenue, reduce expenses, improve quality, enhance reputation - leads institutions to attempt an array of proven and unproven management techniques and approaches.” - From Unintended Consequences of Tuition Discounting by the Lumina Foundation

Tuition discounting - the use of institutional funds to help reduce students’ actual costs of studying, as in scholarships and bursaries - is one of the management approaches referred to in the excerpt above. Tuition discounting came into practice in the late 1970s, gained massive application in the most recent global recession, and remains in wide use today across the global education market. The approach has always provoked debate regarding its effectiveness as well as the negative impact it can have on other areas needing institutional funding (e.g., instruction), and new research only continues the discussion. The Chronicle of Higher Education reports that a survey of 400 private institutions by the National Association of College and University Business Officers (NACUBO) found that institutional discount rates - the share of gross undergraduate tuition and fee revenue given back to students in scholarships, fellowships, and other grants - continued to rise in 2010-11. However, despite the savings this entailed for students, 45 percent of surveyed institutions saw overall enrolment remain flat or drop. And more than half - 53.2 percent - saw a decline or no change in the number of freshmen they enrolled. Some might say the research shows that tuition discounting is ineffective at achieving net enrolment goals … yet others would argue that it’s not so simple and that there are other factors to be considered. For example, the NACUBO survey also found that net tuition revenues increased 5.4 percent between 2009-10 and 2010-11, for various reasons that may or may not include tuition discounting. Last year when an earlier installment of the NACUBO survey found the same trends regarding tuition discounting and net revenues, Natalie Pullaro, manager for research and policy analysis for NACUBO and the report's author, commented, “It's possible that institutions could have had greater losses in net tuition revenue instead of the small gains this year had they not increased the discount rate.” Also, tuition discounting can achieve enrolment goals other than net - or overall - ones, such as helping to tailor enrolments, for example by recruiting high-quality or specialised students. The debate, and the practice of tuition discounting, is quite a fascinating one. In an insightful piece in Inside Higher Ed called “Discounting the Bottom Line,” journalist Kevin Kiley noted:

“Discounting is part of a tug-of-war that colleges and universities play with their enrolment numbers and bottom lines. They place their sticker price beyond the reach of many potential students, but make up the difference between that price and what a student can or will pay through institutional grants and scholarships.

Proponents have argued that there are some psychological benefits to having a high sticker price, such as the perception of quality and high discounting, or the value a student perceives when he is offered a large package.

The strategy pays off financially when enough students can pay the sticker price. But when too few students pay sticker price, too many students need large aid packages, or enrolment numbers aren’t met, colleges and universities that depend on tuition revenue are put in a tight spot financially.”

For an older but still very valuable document on the subject, please see the PDF Unintended Consequences of Tuition Discounting. Sources: The Chronicle of Higher Education, Inside Higher Ed, Lumina Foundation

Most Recent

  • The rise of alternative destinations: Thailand, Poland, and the Philippines Read More
  • Comparing student visa proof of funds requirements across 20 study destinations Read More
  • ICEF Podcast: Start-ups in international education: disrupters or innovators? Read More

Most Popular

  • Canada’s foreign enrolment grew by more than 30% in 2022 Read More
  • Measuring cost of study and cost of living across study destinations Read More
  • Recruiting in the Emirates: Big goals, world-class education, and new scholarships Read More

Because you found this article interesting

The rise of alternative destinations: Thailand, Poland, and the Philippines A growing body of industry research shows that in 2024, international students are considering a wider range of...
Read more
Comparing student visa proof of funds requirements across 20 study destinations In recent months, some major study abroad destinations have increased the amount of available, guaranteed funds that international...
Read more
France hosted 412,000 foreign students in 2022/23 Campus France has released its international student enrolment data for 2022/23, and in contrast to the double-digit percentage...
Read more
The impact of immigration settings, affordability, and job opportunities on international students’ study abroad decisions New research underlines the extent to which international students look closely at work opportunities and immigration policy in...
Read more
ChatGPT for international education marketing: What is “Prompt Engineering?” Many international education marketers are now using ChatGPT, whether it’s the free version (GPT-3) or the paid version...
Read more
Business school survey again signals declining non-EU enrolment in UK The most recent survey from the Chartered Association of Business Schools in the UK reveals that, “International student...
Read more
Canada: Ontario’s cap implementation plan allocates nearly all study permit applications to public colleges and universities On 26 February 2024, the Government of Ontario – Canada’s most-populous province and host to just over half of...
Read more
New Zealand’s international enrolment continued to recover in 2023 New Zealand’s international education sector welcomed significantly more students in 2023 than in 2022, according to data released...
Read more
What are you looking for?
Quick Links